Black Friday fails to lift retail sales in November with retailers facing a painful hangover in 2023
16 December 2022
Jacqui Baker, partner and head of retail at leading audit, tax and consulting firm RSM UK, comments on the November ONS retail sales data, which shows a decrease in retail sales volumes of 0.4%:
‘Christmas shopping got underway for many consumers last month as they took advantage of the Black Friday deals to stock up on household goods and clothing, with sales up 4.4% and 2.1% respectively. Household goods were the only category where prices fell and were down 0.6% month on the month, which implies retailers discounted their goods heavily in a last attempt to shift stock before the end of the year.
‘Food sales increased 0.9% last month helped by the start of the World Cup and households starting to stock up on food, drinks and treats ahead of the Christmas festivities.
‘What’s more worrying is the year-on-year comparison of overall sales, with values increasing 4.2%, but volumes dropping 5.9%, which shows consumers are still willing to go out and spend but are getting a fraction of what they used to get for their money.
‘Unfortunately, Black Friday was not quite the weekend bonanza retailers were banking on. What was meant to be a weekend of offers has turned into a prolonged period of discounting throughout November, which may provide a slight boost to revenues, but will have little impact on bottom lines.
‘With swathes of industrial strikes and extreme weather creating further barriers for consumers to splurge, the chance to recoup losses and offload winter stock will have been cut short in December. It’s likely to be a disappointing end to the year for the retail sector and a painful hangover for some retailers in Q1 of 2023.’
Thomas Pugh, economist at RSM UK, added: ‘The 0.4 m/m fall in retail sales volumes illustrates the toll that soaring inflation is taking on consumer spending. The economic headwinds are just as strong as previously and the downward trend is likely to continue over the next year.
‘Admittedly, inflation has peaked and will fall over the next year. But it is still in double digits and will still be higher than wages for a while, meaning that the cost-of-living crisis will continue. Combine this with soaring mortgage rates and it’s no surprise that depressed consumer spending will hammer retail spending and the wider economy.
‘Indeed, Real Household Disposable Income per person is set to fall more than 7% over the next two years. This is by far the biggest fall on record and would return real incomes back down to their 2014 levels.
‘This is a key reason why we think the economy is already in a recession and will be until Q3 2023 with a peak-to-trough drop in GDP of around 2%, similar to the 1990s recession.’
‘Christmas shopping got underway for many consumers last month as they took advantage of the Black Friday deals to stock up on household goods and clothing, with sales up 4.4% and 2.1% respectively. Household goods were the only category where prices fell and were down 0.6% month on the month, which implies retailers discounted their goods heavily in a last attempt to shift stock before the end of the year.
‘Food sales increased 0.9% last month helped by the start of the World Cup and households starting to stock up on food, drinks and treats ahead of the Christmas festivities.
‘What’s more worrying is the year-on-year comparison of overall sales, with values increasing 4.2%, but volumes dropping 5.9%, which shows consumers are still willing to go out and spend but are getting a fraction of what they used to get for their money.
‘Unfortunately, Black Friday was not quite the weekend bonanza retailers were banking on. What was meant to be a weekend of offers has turned into a prolonged period of discounting throughout November, which may provide a slight boost to revenues, but will have little impact on bottom lines.
‘With swathes of industrial strikes and extreme weather creating further barriers for consumers to splurge, the chance to recoup losses and offload winter stock will have been cut short in December. It’s likely to be a disappointing end to the year for the retail sector and a painful hangover for some retailers in Q1 of 2023.’
Thomas Pugh, economist at RSM UK, added: ‘The 0.4 m/m fall in retail sales volumes illustrates the toll that soaring inflation is taking on consumer spending. The economic headwinds are just as strong as previously and the downward trend is likely to continue over the next year.
‘Admittedly, inflation has peaked and will fall over the next year. But it is still in double digits and will still be higher than wages for a while, meaning that the cost-of-living crisis will continue. Combine this with soaring mortgage rates and it’s no surprise that depressed consumer spending will hammer retail spending and the wider economy.
‘Indeed, Real Household Disposable Income per person is set to fall more than 7% over the next two years. This is by far the biggest fall on record and would return real incomes back down to their 2014 levels.
‘This is a key reason why we think the economy is already in a recession and will be until Q3 2023 with a peak-to-trough drop in GDP of around 2%, similar to the 1990s recession.’
